Beyond the Lists: The Diabetic Food Chart That Finally Made Sense to This Dietitian

My name is Sarah, and for 15 years, I’ve been a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist (RDN).

I’ve dedicated my career to helping people navigate the complex world of food and health.

I had the textbooks, the certifications, and endless lists of “good” and “bad” foods.

Yet, for years, I felt like I was failing my clients with diabetes.

Not because the information was wrong, but because it was overwhelming, fragmented, and, frankly, demoralizing.

The breaking point came with a client I’ll call Roger.

He was a kind, newly diagnosed man in his 60s, determined to get his health on track.

I gave him the standard toolkit: the lists of foods to eat and avoid, the primer on carb counting, the introduction to the Glycemic Index.

He left my office with a folder full of papers and a look of resolve.

Two weeks later, he sat in the same chair, looking utterly defeated.

He described a trip to the grocery store that nearly brought him to tears.¹

He felt like he was navigating a minefield, where every aisle held a potential threat.

“It feels like everything I used to enjoy is poison,” he said, his voice quiet.

“I’m so afraid of making a mistake that I’m barely eating.

And when I do eat something ‘wrong,’ I feel so guilty I just think, ‘what’s the point?’ and the whole day is ruined.”

Roger’s words hit me hard.

He was experiencing the exact psychological traps I’d read about: the “all-or-nothing” thinking, the cycle of restriction and guilt, the emotional eating born from frustration.²

The standard advice, while scientifically sound, had turned food from a source of nourishment and joy into a source of anxiety and failure.

I knew there had to be a better Way.

This article is the story of that better Way. It’s about an epiphany that transformed how I teach diabetes nutrition—a simple, intuitive system that turns confusion into clarity and restriction into empowerment.

It’s the framework that finally helped Roger, and countless clients since, and it all starts with rethinking the problem entirely.

Part 1: The Chaos of Standard Advice – Why We Get Stuck in Traffic

Before we can find a better path, we have to understand why the old maps lead us astray.

The conventional approach to diabetic eating, while well-intentioned, often creates a perfect storm of confusion and psychological distress.

The Maze of “Good” and “Bad” Food Lists

The first tool most people receive is a list of foods to eat and foods to limit or avoid.

On one side, you have non-starchy vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins.

On the other, pastries, sugary drinks, fatty meats, and white bread.³

While this information is factually correct, its presentation is the root of a significant problem.

These binary lists inadvertently frame food in moral terms: “good” versus “bad.” This creates a dangerous psychological dynamic.

When a person eats a “bad” food, like the mashed potatoes at a family dinner, they don’t just see it as a suboptimal nutritional choice; they see it as a personal failing.

This guilt can trigger what researchers call the “it’s already ruined” mentality.²

The thinking goes, “Well, I’ve already blown my diet with these potatoes, so I might as well have the pie, too.” This single event spirals into a cycle of restriction, guilt, and over-indulgence—a pattern that is incredibly destructive for blood sugar management and mental well-being.

This was Roger’s experience in the grocery store: a world divided into good and evil, where one misstep meant total failure.

The Mental Tax of Carb Counting

For many, especially those on mealtime insulin, carb counting is a non-negotiable, life-saving tool.⁴

It involves calculating the grams of carbohydrates in every meal to match medication dosage, with a typical meal containing around 45-75 grams of carbs.⁶

You read labels, use apps, and measure portions to achieve a precise number.⁸

The challenge isn’t the science; it’s the practicality.

The constant calculation imposes a significant mental tax.

It turns meals, which should be a source of pleasure and social connection, into a math problem.

While manageable in a controlled home environment, it becomes a source of high stress in the real world—at a restaurant, a party, or a friend’s house.⁹

The difficulty of accurately estimating carbs in these settings can lead to frustration and, for some, complete abandonment of the practice.

It’s a system that demands laboratory-level precision in a messy, unpredictable world.

The Glycemic Index (GI) – Powerful but Perplexing

The Glycemic Index (GI) adds another layer of complexity.

It’s a brilliant concept that ranks carbohydrate-containing foods on a scale from 0 to 100 based on how quickly they raise blood sugar.¹⁰

For example, lentils have a low GI of 28, while a baked potato has a high GI of over 80, meaning the potato will cause a much faster and sharper rise in blood sugar.¹²

However, the GI is an incomplete equation.

As health organizations like the Mayo Clinic point out, its usefulness has major caveats.¹³

The GI of a food changes dramatically depending on how it’s cooked and what it’s eaten with.

Pairing a high-GI food with protein, fat, or fiber can slow down its absorption significantly.¹⁴

Furthermore, GI doesn’t account for portion size.

Watermelon has a high GI of 72, which scares many people away.

But a typical serving of watermelon is mostly water and has very few carbs, resulting in a low Glycemic

Load (a measure that combines GI and portion size).¹¹

Without this crucial context, the GI becomes just another list of confusing rules, leading people to needlessly fear healthy foods like fruit while potentially overeating low-GI foods that are high in calories.

Part 2: The Epiphany – A Blueprint for Blood Sugar as “Food Traffic Control”

After my frustrating session with Roger, I was aimlessly watching a documentary on urban planning.

The narrator was explaining how a city’s road network functions.

He said the goal isn’t to ban cars; cars are essential for getting people where they need to go.

The goal is to manage the flow, speed, and volume of cars to prevent gridlock.

A lightbulb went off in my head.

This was the perfect analogy for diabetes management.

I grabbed a notebook and started sketching it out:

• The Bloodstream is the City’s Road Network. It’s the essential infrastructure for delivering fuel throughout the body.
• Carbohydrates are the Cars. They are not the enemy. They are the primary vehicles that deliver energy (glucose) to our cells. We need them to function.
• A Blood Sugar Spike is a Traffic Jam. Too many cars (carbs) entering the system at once, or cars moving too fast, creates gridlock. The system gets overwhelmed, and things stop working efficiently.
• Our Job is to be the Traffic Controller.

This simple shift in perspective was revolutionary.

It changed the fundamental question from “What foods are forbidden?” to “How do I manage the traffic?” It meant the old tools weren’t useless; they were just individual components of a larger, unarticulated system.

My clients didn’t need more lists; they needed a control panel.

This “Food Traffic Control” system is built on three simple, intuitive pillars, each corresponding to a traffic light.

Part 3: The Pillars of “Food Traffic Control” (The Printable Charts)

This system organizes all foods into three clear categories.

It’s designed to be printed and put on your fridge—a daily guide that turns complex data into simple, actionable choices.

Pillar I: Green-Light Foods – The Open Roads of Your Diet

Green-Light foods are the foundation of your diet.

Think of them as the city’s infrastructure—the roads, bridges, and tunnels that allow everything else to function smoothly.

These foods have a minimal impact on blood sugar “traffic.” You can and should eat them in abundance at every meal.

This category is built from the food groups that all major health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, recommend as the base of a healthy plate: non-starchy vegetables, lean proteins, and healthy fats.¹⁷

The psychological power of this approach cannot be overstated.

By starting with a vast list of foods you can say “yes” to, we immediately counteract the sense of deprivation and restriction that plagues so many.²

It provides an immediate, positive, and empowering answer to the question, “What can I eat?”

Table 1: Green-Light Foods Chart

Category	Examples
Non-Starchy Vegetables (Fill half your plate)	Leafy Greens (Spinach, Kale, Lettuce), Broccoli, Cauliflower, Bell Peppers, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Zucchini, Mushrooms, Asparagus, Green Beans, Onions 3
Lean Proteins (Animal-Based)	Salmon, Tuna, Sardines, Cod, Chicken Breast (skinless), Turkey, Eggs, Lean Beef (Sirloin, Tenderloin), Low-fat Cottage Cheese 3
Lean Proteins (Plant-Based)	Tofu, Tempeh, Edamame, Plant-based meat substitutes 19
Healthy Fats (Use for cooking & flavor)	Avocado, Olive Oil, Canola Oil, Nuts (Almonds, Walnuts), Seeds (Chia, Flax, Pumpkin), Olives 3

Pillar II: Yellow-Light Foods – Managing Your Main Arteries

Yellow-Light foods are the “cars” of our system—the quality carbohydrate foods that provide essential energy.

This group includes fruits, starchy vegetables, whole grains, and legumes.²¹

They are not “bad,” but like traffic on a main artery, they must be managed to prevent jams.

This is where we create our unified control panel.

Instead of juggling three separate concepts, we integrate them.

To manage traffic, you need to control two things:

1. Volume: The number of cars on the road. This is your Portion Size or Carb Count.
2. Speed: How fast the cars are moving. This is the Glycemic Index (GI).

The chart below is the heart of the Traffic Control system.

It allows you to see both the volume (carbs) and speed (GI) of a food in one place.

For example, you can see that while both chickpeas and brown rice are healthy choices, chickpeas have both a lower carb count per serving and a much lower GI, making them a “slower, less crowded” option.

This empowers you to make nuanced decisions instead of just following rigid rules.

Table 2: The Yellow-Light Carbohydrate Navigator

Food Item	Standard Serving Size	Approx. Carb Grams (Volume)	Glycemic Index (Speed)	GI Category
FRUITS
Apple	1 medium	25 g	36	Low
Banana (ripe)	1 medium	27 g	51	Low
Blueberries	1 cup	21 g	53	Low
Grapes	1 cup	28 g	59	Medium
Orange	1 medium	15 g	45	Low
Watermelon	1 cup, diced	11 g	72	High
STARCHY VEGETABLES & LEGUMES
Chickpeas	1/2 cup, cooked	20 g	28-33	Low
Corn	1/2 cup	21 g	52-60	Low-Medium
Lentils	1/2 cup, cooked	20 g	32	Low
Sweet Potato	1/2 cup, cubed	20 g	54-70	Low-High
Green Peas	1/2 cup	12 g	51-54	Low
WHOLE GRAINS
Brown Rice	1/2 cup, cooked	22 g	55-68	Low-Medium
Quinoa	1/2 cup, cooked	20 g	53	Low
Rolled Oats	1/2 cup, dry	27 g	50-55	Low
Whole Wheat Bread	1 slice	14 g	51-74	Low-High
Whole Wheat Pasta	1/2 cup, cooked	21 g	42-59	Low-Medium
DAIRY
Milk (low-fat)	1 cup	12 g	31-37	Low
Plain Yogurt (low-fat)	6 oz	12 g	21-33	Low

(Note: GI values are approximate and can vary.

Data compiled from.⁶

)

Pillar III: Red-Light Foods – Recognizing and Rerouting Traffic Jams

Red-Light foods are items that are highly likely to cause blood sugar “gridlock.” This is typically due to high levels of processing, added sugars, and/or unhealthy fats, which lead to a rapid influx of “cars” with very little nutritional value.³

The crucial mindset shift here is moving from “forbidden” to “predictable outcome.” Eating a cookie is not a moral failure; it is a predictable traffic event.

A driver knows that trying to merge onto a highway during peak rush hour will result in sitting in traffic.

It’s not a moral issue, it’s a strategic one.

By framing these foods as “known traffic jams,” we remove the guilt and empower the individual to make a conscious choice.

You can decide if the predictable jam is worth it, and if so, how you might mitigate it (e.g., by having a very small portion or taking a walk after).

Table 3: The Red-Light Foods Chart

Food/Category	The “Traffic Jam” Effect (Why it’s a Red Light)
Sugary Beverages (Soda, Juice, Sweet Tea)	Delivers a massive, rapid sugar spike with no fiber to slow it down. The equivalent of a highway pile-up.3
Refined Grains (White Bread, White Rice, White Pasta)	Stripped of fiber during processing, they are digested very quickly, leading to a fast blood sugar rise.3
Pastries & Baked Goods (Donuts, Cakes, Cookies)	A combination of refined flour, sugar, and often unhealthy fats creates a perfect storm for blood sugar and inflammation.3
Packaged Snacks (Chips, Pretzels, Candy)	Highly processed, low in nutrients, and designed to be eaten in large quantities, causing rapid and significant traffic.3
Fried Foods (French Fries, Fried Chicken)	High in unhealthy fats and often paired with refined carbohydrates, creating a slow-to-clear, system-clogging traffic jam.3

Part 4: Your Daily Commute – Building Meals with the “Traffic Control” System

With our new map, building a healthy meal becomes simple.

The best visual guide for this is the Diabetes Plate Method, which perfectly mirrors our system.¹⁴

Imagine your 9-inch plate is your city grid for a single meal:

• Fill Half (1/2) of your plate with Green-Light non-starchy vegetables. This builds your meal on a foundation of open roads.
• Fill One-Quarter (1/4) of your plate with Green-Light lean protein. These are your essential services, helping to build and repair.
• Fill One-Quarter (1/4) of your plate with Yellow-Light quality carbohydrates. Use the Navigator Chart to choose your “cars” wisely, balancing volume and speed.

Sample Day’s “Commute”:

• Breakfast: A Green-Light two-egg omelet with spinach and mushrooms. Paired with one slice of Yellow-Light whole wheat toast (Volume: ~14g carbs, Speed: Low-High GI) and a side of Yellow-Light berries (Volume: ~15g carbs, Speed: Low GI).
• Lunch: A large Green-Light salad base with tomatoes, cucumbers, and bell peppers, topped with Green-Light grilled salmon. For carbs, add 1/2 cup of Yellow-Light chickpeas (Volume: ~20g carbs, Speed: Low GI).
• Dinner: A Green-Light chicken breast, baked. Served with a large portion of Green-Light roasted broccoli and cauliflower. Paired with 1/2 cup of Yellow-Light quinoa (Volume: ~20g carbs, Speed: Low GI).

Part 5: Navigating Rush Hour, Detours, and Roadblocks

Life isn’t a perfectly planned commute.

The true test of any system is how it performs under pressure.

Eating Out & Social Gatherings (“Navigating Unfamiliar Roads”)

The Challenge: Restaurant menus are filled with hidden Red-Lights, and social pressure can be intense.²⁸

The System Solution: Use the Traffic Light system as your menu guide.

1. Scan for Green-Light words: “Grilled,” “baked,” “steamed,” “roasted,” “salad.”
2. Identify the Yellow-Light items: Rice, potatoes, pasta, bread. Plan your portion. Ask for a half-portion or share.
3. Spot the potential Red-Lights: “Fried,” “creamy,” “breaded,” “glazed.” Ask for sauces and dressings on the side to control the amount.⁹

Holidays & Special Occasions (“Planning for Rush Hour”)

The Challenge: Festive meals are often dense with Red- and Yellow-Light foods.

The System Solution: Plan for the traffic.

1. Don’t arrive starving. Have a small Green-Light snack (like a handful of nuts) before you go.
2. Survey the scene. At the buffet, fill your plate first with salads and vegetables (Green-Lights).
3. Make a conscious choice. Pick one or two Yellow- or Red-Light favorites to enjoy in a small portion. Savor them mindfully. You are not “cheating”; you are making a planned decision to navigate a bit of traffic.³⁰
4. Get moving. A post-meal walk is a great way to help “clear the roads” and manage blood sugar.

Emotional Eating & Cravings (“Handling Unexpected Detours”)

The Challenge: Stress, sadness, or boredom can trigger cravings for Red-Light comfort foods.²

The System Solution: Use the system to build mindfulness.

1. Pause and identify. When a craving hits, ask: “Is this physical hunger or an emotional detour?”
2. Find a non-food route. If it’s emotional, the solution isn’t food. Try a short walk, listening to music, or calling a friend.²
3. If you choose food, choose consciously. Acknowledge the feeling. “I feel stressed, and I want a cookie.” Then, use the system. “I know that cookie is a Red-Light food that will cause a traffic jam. Is that what I really want? Perhaps a Yellow-Light apple with some Green-Light peanut butter would satisfy my need for something sweet and crunchy without the gridlock.” This transforms a reactive, guilt-ridden moment into a proactive, empowered decision.

Conclusion: Becoming a Confident Driver of Your Health

When I shared this “Food Traffic Control” system with Roger, I saw the tension leave his shoulders.

He wasn’t a failure; he was just trying to navigate a complex city with a terrible map.

This system gave him a clear, intuitive, and, most importantly, non-judgmental way to make choices.

He started seeing the grocery store not as a minefield, but as a depot from which he could plan his daily commute.

He learned to manage the flow of traffic in his body, and his health, confidence, and relationship with food transformed.

Managing diabetes isn’t about deprivation.

It’s about having a flexible and forgiving system for making decisions.

It’s about understanding that you are the traffic controller, with the power to manage the flow, speed, and volume of fuel your body needs.

By shifting your perspective from “good vs. bad” to “Green, Yellow, and Red,” you can move beyond the endless, confusing lists and become a confident driver on your own road to better health.

---

Table 4: The “Food Traffic Control” System At-a-Glance

Green Light: Eat Freely & Abundantly	Yellow Light: Manage Volume & Speed	Red Light: Be Aware & Reduce
Concept: These foods are the foundation of your diet. They have minimal impact on blood sugar. Fill your plate with them!	Concept: These quality carbs are your body’s fuel. Manage them by controlling Portion Size (Volume) and Glycemic Index (Speed).	Concept: These foods are known to cause blood sugar “traffic jams.” This isn’t about guilt, but awareness. Reduce them and choose mindfully.
Examples:	Examples (Serving/Carbs/GI):	Examples:
– All Non-Starchy Veggies (Broccoli, Spinach, Peppers)	– Apple: 1 med / 25g / Low	– Sugary Drinks (Soda, Juice)
– Lean Proteins (Chicken, Fish, Tofu, Eggs)	– Sweet Potato: 1/2 cup / 20g / Low-High	– Refined Grains (White Bread, White Rice)
– Healthy Fats (Avocado, Olive Oil, Nuts, Seeds)	– Chickpeas: 1/2 cup / 20g / Low	– Pastries, Cookies, Cake
	– Oatmeal: 1/2 cup / 27g / Low	– Packaged Snacks (Chips, Candy)
	– Quinoa: 1/2 cup / 20g / Low	– Fried Foods
Your Plate: Fill 1/2 with Non-Starchy Veggies + 1/4 with Lean Protein.	Your Plate: Fill 1/4 with a Yellow-Light choice, using the Navigator chart to guide you.	Your Plate: Enjoy on occasion, in small amounts, and with a plan to manage the “traffic.”

Works cited

1. Sharing My Story: Roger | American Diabetes Association, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetes.org/blog/sharing-my-story-roger-hare
2. What You Should Know About Eating Behaviors and Diabetes | SBM …, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.sbm.org/healthy-living/what-you-should-know-about-eating-behaviors-and-diabetes
3. Diabetes Diet: Best Foods, Recipes, Meal Plans | Cooper University Health Care, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.cooperhealth.org/services/diabetes-type-2/diet
4. How to Count Carbs for Diabetes | Carb Calculator & Meal Planning, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetes.org/food-nutrition/understanding-carbs/carb-counting-and-diabetes
5. Type 1 Diabetes Carbohydrate Counting – Breakthrough T1D, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.breakthrought1d.org/daily-management/carb-counting/
6. Carb Counting | Diabetes – CDC, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/healthy-eating/carb-counting-manage-blood-sugar.html
7. Diabetes Plate Method | UGA Cooperative Extension, accessed August 6, 2025, https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=C1323-06&title=diabetes-plate-method
8. Carbohydrate Counting for People with Diabetes – Stanford Health Care, accessed August 6, 2025, https://stanfordhealthcare.org/content/dam/SHC/treatments/h/docs/hearttransplant-pdf-carbohydratecounting.pdf
9. Eating Out When You Have Diabetes | Kaiser Permanente, accessed August 6, 2025, https://healthy.kaiserpermanente.org/health-wellness/health-encyclopedia/he.eating-out-when-you-have-diabetes.uq2544abc
10. Glycemic index and diabetes: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia, accessed August 6, 2025, https://medlineplus.gov/ency/patientinstructions/000941.htm
11. Glycemic Index and Glycemic Load | Linus Pauling Institute | Oregon State University, accessed August 6, 2025, https://lpi.oregonstate.edu/mic/food-beverages/glycemic-index-glycemic-load
12. GLYCEMIC INDEX CHART, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.arheart.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/2020.10.06-Glycemic-Index-Handout.pdf
13. Glycemic index: A helpful tool for diabetes? – Mayo Clinic, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/diabetes/expert-answers/diabetes/faq-20058466
14. Diabetes Meal Planning | Diabetes | CDC, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/healthy-eating/diabetes-meal-planning.html
15. The 3 R’s of Glycemic Index: Recommendations, Research, and the Real World, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetesjournals.org/clinical/article/29/4/155/31280/The-3-R-s-of-Glycemic-Index-Recommendations
16. Your guide to a heart-healthy glycemic index and glycemic load – Cleveland HeartLab, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.clevelandheartlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Quest-CHL-Glycemic-Index.pdf
17. Eating Well & Managing Diabetes | ADA, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetes.org/food-nutrition/eating-healthy
18. Nutrition for Life: Diabetes Plate Method, accessed August 6, 2025, https://professional.diabetes.org/sites/dpro/files/2023-12/plan_your_plate.pdf
19. What is the Diabetes Plate?, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetesfoodhub.org/blog/what-diabetes-plate
20. Complete List of Foods to Eat When You Have Diabetes—and What to Limit – EatingWell, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.eatingwell.com/article/2059770/complete-list-of-foods-to-eat-when-you-have-diabetes-and-what-to-limit/
21. Carbs and Diabetes | ADA, accessed August 6, 2025, https://diabetes.org/food-nutrition/understanding-carbs
22. Glycemic Index Food Guide Diabetes Canada, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.diabetes.ca/managing-my-diabetes/tools—resources/glycemic-index-(gi)-food-guide
23. Glycemic Index – Whole Health Library – VA.gov, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.va.gov/WHOLEHEALTHLIBRARY/tools/glycemic-index.asp
24. Glycemic Index Food Guide – Clinical Practice Guidelines, accessed August 6, 2025, https://guidelines.diabetes.ca/GuideLines/media/Docs/Patient%20Resources/glycemic-index-food-guide.pdf
25. Glycemic Index Chart for Common Foods – Verywell Health, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.verywellhealth.com/glycemic-index-chart-for-common-foods-1087476
26. Low and High Glycemic Index Charts and Their Limitations – ZOE, accessed August 6, 2025, https://zoe.com/learn/glycemic-index-chart
27. Diabetes: How To Build Your Plate – Health Library | NewYork-Presbyterian, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.nyp.org/healthlibrary/multimedia/diabetes-how-to-build-your-plate
28. Diabetes, gatherings, food and uninvited opinions on what to eat, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.diabetesaustralia.com.au/blog/diabetes-gatherings-and-food/
29. 5 Tips for Dining Out with Diabetes: Social Pressure & Food Choices | GlucoSense, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.glucosense.ai/blog/social-pressures-and-food-choices-with-diabetes
30. Mastering Diabetes Management During Social Gatherings and Festivities – Apollo 247, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.apollo247.com/blog/article/diabetes-management-during-social-gatherings-and-festivities
31. Your feelings about food and diabetes, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.diabetes.org.uk/living-with-diabetes/emotional-wellbeing/your-feelings-about-food-and-diabetes