Beyond the Number: Why “Mean Pain” Is the Wrong Target, and How I Reclaimed My Life by Recalibrating My Body’s Alarm System

Introduction: The Tyranny of the 7-out-of-10

For years, my life was governed by a number.

As a clinical psychologist specializing in pain, I understood the tools of the trade.

But as a person living with chronic pain, I became a prisoner to them.

My days were measured not in moments of joy or accomplishment, but by a single digit on a 0-to-10 scale.

My entire sense of well-being was held hostage by my “mean pain” score—the clinical term for the average pain level a patient reports over a set period.¹

I followed all the standard advice: I saw specialists, I tried the medications, I did the gentle exercises, I paced myself.²

Yet, my world kept shrinking.

The pain, a relentless companion, wasn’t just a physical sensation; it was a thief, stealing my ability to work, my presence in my relationships, and my own mental peace, leaving behind a trail of frustration, anxiety, and isolation.⁵

The medical system, in its quest for a quantifiable metric, had handed me a target: lower the number.

My “mean pain” became the sole indicator of progress.

A “good day” was a 4; a “bad day” was an 8.

This relentless focus on the number is a cornerstone of pain research and clinical practice, where the Numerical Rating Scale (NRS) is used to track outcomes and guide treatment.⁸

But this focus creates a subtle and insidious trap.

By making the number the enemy, the system inadvertently teaches patients to become hyper-vigilant, to constantly monitor and appraise their internal state.

This intense focus, as research into the cognitive components of pain shows, can paradoxically amplify the very sensation you’re trying to reduce.⁹

The tool designed to measure the problem becomes a mechanism that reinforces it.

I remember one particular Saturday with piercing clarity.

My “mean pain” for the week had been a “manageable” 5.

On paper, I was succeeding.

But my family was celebrating my daughter’s birthday in the park, and I was on the couch, paralyzed.

It wasn’t the intensity of the pain that stopped me; it was the all-consuming fear of the pain.

The fear that standing up would trigger a flare-up, that walking would cost me the next two days, that a simple sneeze could send me to my knees.¹⁰

My pain score was a 5, but my life score was a zero.

In that moment of heartbreaking stillness, I realized the futility of my quest.

Chasing a lower number wasn’t giving me my life back.

I had to question everything I thought I knew, not just as a patient, but as a clinician.

The entire model was wrong.

Part I: The Flawed Blueprint – Why Our Approach to Pain Is Broken

The foundation of my old approach—and the conventional approach to pain management—was built on the shaky ground of the “mean pain” score.

This single number is treated as an objective measure, yet research reveals it is anything but.

Studies comparing NRS ratings to pain categories like “mild, moderate, and severe” find that the cutoffs are wildly inconsistent.

A “7” for a person with cancer pain might mean something entirely different than a “7” for someone with diabetic neuropathy or chronic back pain.⁸

The thresholds even shift depending on whether a person is rating their “average” pain versus their “worst” pain.⁸

This proves the number is not a direct readout of tissue damage but a deeply subjective experience colored by diagnosis, context, and emotion.

Relying on it is like trying to navigate the intricate streets of a city using a map that only shows the average daily temperature.

It’s data, but it’s not the right data to get you where you need to go.

This flawed metric is the entry point to a treatment model that frequently fails those with chronic pain.

The standard of care, often visualized as the World Health Organization (WHO) “treatment ladder,” is a sequential approach that escalates from non-opioids to so-called “weak” and then “strong” opioids, often supplemented by injections and other interventions.¹¹

This model is designed for acute pain, where there is a clear link between tissue damage and the pain signal.

However, for a significant portion of chronic pain sufferers, this ladder leads nowhere.

Patients find themselves climbing rungs with minimal relief, sometimes seeing dozens of specialists without finding a sustainable solution.¹¹

The consequences of this systemic failure are devastating.

When treatments aimed at the body don’t work, patients are often dismissed or labeled as “drug seekers” or “difficult”.¹¹

They face the psychological torment of having their medication tapered or denied, leading to uncontrolled pain and intense distress.¹⁴

This cycle of temporary fixes and failures feeds a powerful psychological process known as the fear-avoidance model.¹⁵

Pain becomes associated with danger.

Movement, once a source of joy, becomes a perceived threat.

This fear is not static; it spreads through a process of symbolic generalization, where even neutral movements or thoughts related to the original injury can trigger fear and pain.¹⁵

The result is a shrinking world, where physical deconditioning, social withdrawal, and a profound loss of self are the true pathologies.³

The conventional treatment model fails not because the individual therapies are inherently bad, but because the underlying paradigm fundamentally misdiagnoses the nature of chronic pain.

The biomedical model assumes a “hardware” problem: a damaged part of the body is sending distress signals, and the solution is to block those signals.¹⁶

But for many, chronic pain is not a hardware problem; it’s a “software” problem.

The issue is no longer in the tissues but in the central nervous system itself, which has become rewired and hypersensitive—a state known as nociplastic pain or central sensitization.¹⁷

Applying a hardware solution like an opioid or an injection to a software bug is like trying to fix a computer virus by replacing the monitor.

It’s aimed at the wrong target, which is why so many patients suffer despite having “normal” scans and why treatments focused on the periphery so often fail.¹⁹

Part II: The Epiphany – Pain Isn’t a Measure of Damage, It’s a Misguided Security System

My breakthrough, the epiphany that changed everything, was realizing that my pain system wasn’t a broken messenger of damage.

It was a hyper-vigilant, malfunctioning security system.

Think of it this way:

• Acute Pain is a functional alarm. You touch a hot stove (a real threat). The alarm (pain) sounds loudly. You reflexively pull your hand away (a protective action). The threat is neutralized, and the alarm system resets and turns off. It has done its job perfectly.²¹
• Chronic Pain is a faulty, over-sensitive alarm. Perhaps there was an initial break-in (an old injury), but the threat is long gone. However, the alarm’s software has been corrupted. It’s now stuck on high alert, its sensors dialed up to maximum sensitivity.¹⁷ Now, the rustle of leaves outside (a light touch), the mailman walking up the path (a normal movement), or even the memory of the last break-in (a stressful thought) is enough to trigger a full-blown siren. The “mean pain” score is simply the volume of that siren; it tells you nothing about whether there’s a real burglar in the house.

This analogy isn’t just a folksy metaphor; it’s grounded in decades of pain science.

The first major clue came in the 1960s with the Gate Control Theory.²²

Researchers discovered that the spinal cord contains nerve “gates” that can modulate pain signals before they ever reach the brain.

Non-painful stimuli, like rubbing a sore spot, activate large nerve fibers that can effectively “close the gate” on pain signals carried by smaller nerve fibers.²³

This was the revolutionary discovery of the alarm system’s control panel.

It proved that pain wasn’t a simple one-way street from body to brain; it was a dynamic process that the nervous system itself could regulate.

The core of the “faulty alarm” is a process called Central Sensitization.

This is the scientific term for the nervous system’s software becoming corrupted.

The neurons in the spinal cord and brain become persistently hyper-reactive, amplifying signals.¹⁷

This explains the bizarre and frustrating symptoms of chronic pain:

• Allodynia: This is the alarm screaming when the mailman approaches. A stimulus that shouldn’t hurt, like the touch of bedsheets or a gentle massage, is now perceived as painful.²⁵
• Hyperalgesia: This is the alarm blaring like there’s a battering ram at the door when a small rock hits the window. A mildly painful stimulus, like a small bump, feels excruciatingly painful.²⁵
• Spreading Symptoms: The faulty wiring can affect the entire grid. This is why pain can spread to other parts of the body and why people develop hypersensitivity to light, sounds, and smells, along with debilitating “brain fog,” fatigue, and mood disturbances. It’s the entire system on high alert.²⁵

Finally, the Biopsychosocial Model explains the environment that keeps this faulty alarm on high alert.¹⁶

The alarm system isn’t in a vacuum.

Psychological factors like fear, anxiety, and catastrophic thinking act like a constant storm raging outside, making the sensitive alarm more likely to trigger at the slightest gust of wind.⁹

Social factors like isolation or disbelief from loved ones create an unsafe “neighborhood,” convincing the alarm system that it must remain at maximum vigilance to protect you.⁵

This shift in understanding is profound, moving from a simplistic mechanical view to a holistic systems view.

Feature	Old Model (Biomedical / Pain Score Focus)	New Model (Biopsychosocial / Faulty Alarm System)
Primary Cause of Pain	Assumed to be ongoing tissue damage or structural abnormality.	A hypersensitive, dysregulated nervous system (Central Sensitization). Pain is a faulty output, not a reliable input.
Meaning of Pain Signal	A direct measure of damage in the body. “More pain = more damage.”	A danger signal from an overprotective system. “More pain = more perceived threat,” not more damage.
Primary Goal of Treatment	Reduce the “mean pain” score. Eliminate the sensation of pain.	Recalibrate the nervous system. Increase function and quality of life, even if sensation remains.
View of Flare-ups	A sign of re-injury or worsening tissue damage. A failure of treatment.	A predictable system overreaction. An opportunity to practice new skills and provide the system with safety signals.
Role of the Patient	Passive recipient of treatments (pills, injections, surgery).	Active architect of their recovery. Responsible for retraining their brain and nervous system.
Role of Thoughts/Emotions	Seen as a secondary reaction to pain.	A primary driver that can sensitize or de-sensitize the nervous system. Part of the core problem and solution.

Part III: The New Framework – A 3-Pillar Guide to Recalibrating Your Pain System

My epiphany led me to a new path—one focused not on silencing the alarm, but on recalibrating the entire system.

This is the framework I used to reclaim my own life and the one I now use to guide others.

It is an active process of retraining the brain and nervous system, built on three synergistic pillars.

Pillar	Core Objective	Key Techniques & Practices
Pillar 1: De-escalate the Threat	Change your relationship with the pain signal. Stop fighting the alarm.	Acceptance, Cognitive Defusion (ACT), Mindfulness, Pain Science Education.
Pillar 2: Rewire the System	Provide the nervous system with new, “safe” data to overwrite faulty programming.	Values-Based Goal Setting (ACT), Graded Exposure, Behavioral Activation (CBT), Pacing, Safe Movement.
Pillar 3: Secure the Environment	Regulate the nervous system by optimizing biopsychosocial inputs.	Restorative Sleep Hygiene, Anti-inflammatory Nutrition, Stress Management (Breathwork), Building Social Support.

Pillar 1: De-escalate the Threat (Mindset & Acceptance)

The first step in recalibrating a faulty alarm is to stop treating every sound it makes as a five-alarm fire.

The constant battle against the sensation of pain is, itself, a powerful danger signal to the brain that keeps the system on high alert.

The goal of this pillar is to de-escalate the perceived threat by fundamentally changing your relationship with the pain signal.

This is where the principles of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) become transformative.²⁸

ACT teaches that while pain

hurts, it is the struggle with pain that causes suffering.²⁹

The key is to cultivate psychological flexibility.

This involves making room for uncomfortable sensations without letting them dictate your life.

Acceptance is not resignation; it is the active choice to stop wasting energy fighting a sensation, which in turn reduces the emotional “hot” component that makes pain so distressing.⁹

We then use

Cognitive Defusion to create distance from our thoughts.

A thought like “My back is ruined, I’ll never get better” is not treated as an objective fact, but simply as a string of words passing through the mind.

By observing the thought instead of fusing with it, we unhook it from the panic response that keeps the alarm blaring.²⁸

Finally,

Present Moment Awareness, or mindfulness, grounds us in the here and now, allowing us to notice sensations without judgment and preventing our minds from spiraling into catastrophic future scenarios.²⁸

Pillar 2: Rewire the System (Action & Values)

Once you’ve lowered the immediate sense of threat, the next step is to actively provide the nervous system with new data—evidence that contradicts its faulty programming.

This pillar is about proving to the alarm system that movement and activity are safe.

It requires courage, but it is the engine of neuroplastic change.

This process must be driven by what truly matters to you.

Before you can move forward, you must first clarify your Values.³⁰

What kind of person do you want to be? What gives your life meaning and purpose, separate from pain? This shifts the entire goal of recovery.

You are no longer working to “get rid of pain”; you are working to “re-engage with a life of value.” This provides the profound motivation needed for the challenging work ahead.

With your values as your compass, you can begin Committed Action.

This involves blending ACT’s values-driven approach with the structured techniques of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), such as behavioral activation and graded exposure.³²

You choose a valued activity you’ve been avoiding—perhaps walking in the park with a friend—and break it down into tiny, manageable, non-threatening steps.

Maybe week one is just putting on your walking shoes and stepping out the front door for 30 seconds.

Week two might be walking to the end of the driveway.

Each tiny, successful step is a deposit of “safety evidence” in the brain’s Bank. It slowly and systematically rewires the learned association between movement and danger, directly dismantling the fear-avoidance cycle that keeps so many people trapped.¹⁵

Pillar 3: Secure the Environment (Lifestyle & Support)

The final pillar addresses the broader biological and social factors that set the baseline sensitivity of your nervous system.

You can have the most sophisticated alarm system in the world, but if it’s in a house with flickering electricity, in the middle of a hurricane, in a dangerous neighborhood, it’s going to be unreliable.

This pillar is about creating a calm and stable environment for your nervous system to thrive in.

This involves optimizing foundational biological inputs.

Restorative Sleep is non-negotiable.

Poor sleep is known to sensitize the nervous system and lower pain thresholds.²

Implementing strict sleep hygiene—consistent bedtimes and wake times, creating a dark and cool environment—is a powerful intervention.

Similarly, while no diet is a magic cure, focusing on

Anti-inflammatory Nutrition and reducing processed foods can help calm systemic inflammation that contributes to nervous system sensitivity.⁴

Equally important is managing the “weather” of stress.

Techniques like diaphragmatic breathing directly activate the parasympathetic nervous system, our “rest and digest” state, which acts as a natural brake on the “fight or flight” response that amplifies pain.³⁴

Finally, you must secure your “neighborhood” by

Building a Support System.

This means finding people who understand, sharing your story, and educating loved ones on how to provide helpful encouragement rather than unhelpful enabling behaviors.²

These three pillars do not work in isolation.

They form a powerful, self-reinforcing upward spiral.

De-escalating the threat in Pillar 1 makes the actions of Pillar 2 feel less daunting.

Successfully taking those actions in Pillar 2 provides concrete proof that the catastrophic fears of Pillar 1 are unfounded.

And optimizing the biological and social environment in Pillar 3 lowers the baseline reactivity of the entire system, making the work of the other two pillars easier and more effective.

This is the practical, lived application of the biopsychosocial model in action.

Conclusion: From Pain Manager to Life Participant

Looking back, the person who was a prisoner to the 7-out-of-10 seems like a stranger.

My journey from that couch to where I am today was not about finding a magic bullet to erase the sensation of pain.

It was about a fundamental paradigm shift.

My success story isn’t a pain score of zero; it’s a photo from last month of me on a hiking trail, something my old self would have considered an impossible fantasy.

The sensations are still there sometimes, like background static, but they no longer have the power to write the script of my life.³⁵

The promise of this new framework is not a life without pain, but a life that is no longer defined or limited by it.

It is a profound identity shift from being a passive “pain manager,” constantly reacting to a number, to an active “life participant,” proactively engaging with your values.

The most hopeful message from modern neuroscience is that of neuroplasticity: your brain can and does change.³⁵

Emerging research into the intricate links between the nervous system and the immune system continues to validate this holistic, systems-based approach.³⁷

You are not broken.

Your alarm system is simply doing its job too well, stuck in an overprotective mode.

By understanding its language and providing it with new information—information of safety, value, and resilience—you have the power to recalibrate the system and, step by step, reclaim your life.

Works cited

1. A combination of pain indices based on momentary assessments can predict placebo response in patients with fibromyalgia syndrome – PubMed Central, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7854765/
2. 10 ways to reduce pain – NHS, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/pain/10-ways-to-ease-pain/
3. Supporting loved one with chronic pain – Mayo Clinic Health System, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/hometown-health/speaking-of-health/supporting-loved-one-with-chronic-pain
4. Manage chronic pain with these 6 tips | Gundersen Health System, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.gundersenhealth.org/health-wellness/aging-well/manage-chronic-pain-with-these-6-tips
5. A Picture of Pain: What Life is Really Like with Chronic Pain – Pfizer, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.pfizer.com/news/articles/a_picture_of_pain_what_life_is_really_like_with_chronic_pain
6. Chronic Pain and Mental Health, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://mhanational.org/resources/chronic-pain-and-mental-health/
7. 20 Things People With Chronic Pain Don’t Want You to Know, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.thepainexpertsofarizona.com/blog/20-things-people-with-chronic-pain-dont-want-you-to-know/
8. Defining mild, moderate, and severe pain in persons with multiple sclerosis – PMC, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3473137/
9. Enduring pain for money: decisions based on the perception and memory of pain – Carnegie Mellon University, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.cmu.edu/dietrich/sds/docs/loewenstein/EnduringPain.pdf
10. Megan’s Story: Movement Is Key to Living with Chronic Pain, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.sralab.org/articles/patient-story/megans-story-movement-key-living-chronic-pain
11. Chronic Pain Patients Who Fail Standard Treatment – MedCentral, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.medcentral.com/pain/chronic/chronic-pain-patients-who-fail-standard-treatment
12. Managing Chronic Pain: It Takes a Village – University Hospitals, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.uhhospitals.org/blog/articles/2023/03/managing-chronic-pain-it-takes-a-village
13. Why Traditional Pain Management Doesn’t Work for Many With Chronic Pain, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://michiganih.com/why-traditional-pain-management-doesnt-work-for-many-with-chronic-pain/
14. Problems accessing pain care, and the adverse outcomes among adults with chronic pain: a cross-sectional survey study – PMC – PubMed Central, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11853623/
15. Words putting pain in motion: the generalization of pain-related fear within an artificial stimulus category – Frontiers, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00520/full
16. Evaluating Psychosocial Contributions to Chronic Pain Outcomes …, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6067990/
17. Central Pain Syndrome – StatPearls – NCBI Bookshelf, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK553027/
18. Nociplastic pain – Wikipedia, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nociplastic_pain
19. How To Explain Central Sensitization To Patients – Pathways Pain Relief, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.pathways.health/blog/how-to-explain-central-sensitization-to-patients/
20. Real stories of recovery – Tame the Beast, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.tamethebeast.org/stories
21. Chronic pain is like… The clinical use of analogy and metaphor in the treatment of chronic pain in children – Pediatric Pain Letter, accessed on August 12, 2025, http://ppl.childpain.org/issues/v15n1_2013/v15n1_coakley.shtml
22. Gate control theory | EBSCO Research Starters, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/anatomy-and-physiology/gate-control-theory
23. Gate control theory – Wikipedia, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gate_control_theory
24. Gate Control Theory of Pain – Physiopedia, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.physio-pedia.com/Gate_Control_Theory_of_Pain
25. What is Central Sensitization? — Institute for Chronic Pain, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.instituteforchronicpain.org/understanding-chronic-pain/what-is-chronic-pain/what-is-central-sensitization
26. Central Sensitization: When It Is Not “All in Your Head” | AAFP, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2023/0100/curbside-central-sensitization.html
27. Biopsychosocial Approach to Assessing and Managing Patients with Chronic Pain – PubMed, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26614718/
28. How Acceptance and Commitment Therapy is Used in Pain Management | San Jose, CA, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://myalliedpain.com/how-acceptance-and-commitment-therapy-is-used-in-pain-management/
29. Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) for Chronic Pain, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://integrativepainscienceinstitute.com/acceptance-and-commitment-therapy-act-for-chronic-pain/
30. What is ACT and how can it help you with your chronic pain? – Pathways, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.pathways.health/blog/what-is-act-and-how-can-it-help-you-with-your-chronic-pain/
31. Group ACT for Chronic Pain – Evidence Based, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://evidencebasedgrouptherapy.org/treatment/group-act-for-chronic-pain/
32. Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Individuals With Chronic Pain – American Psychological Association, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/amp-a0035747.pdf
33. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) | Pain Management Education at UCSF, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://pain.ucsf.edu/nonpharmacological-pain-management/cognitive-behavioral-therapy-cbt
34. 11 Tips for Living With Chronic Pain – WebMD, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.webmd.com/pain-management/11-tips-for-living-with-chronic-pain
35. Success stories | The Pain Recovery Program | Chronic Neuroplastic Pain Recovery | Mind Body Pain Management | Pain Reprocessing Therapy, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.thepainrecoveryprogram.com/success-stories
36. Living With, and Managing, Chronic Pain: A Patient’s Story – MedCentral, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.medcentral.com/pain/chronic/living-managing-chronic-pain-patient-story
37. New Developments in Pain Research – NYAS – The New York Academy of Sciences, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://www.nyas.org/shaping-science/events/ebriefing/new-developments-in-pain-research/
38. Pain and the immune system: emerging concepts of IgG-mediated autoimmune pain and immunotherapies | Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, accessed on August 12, 2025, https://jnnp.bmj.com/content/91/2/177